Modeling UI interactions with XState

We've recently started using XState at work for separating business logic from the UI.

Modeling UI interactions with it which previously relied on bits and pieces of scattered state is now a lot simpler.

Consider a simple interaction for an element with the following spec:

• On initial page load, the element is visible
• After 3 seconds, the element disappears
• Any time after that, if the element is hovered by the user, we show the element
  • When hover ends, we again delay hiding it for 3 seconds, similar to initial load

Breakdown

A nice little interaction for showing that extra controls exist but keeping them out of view. Based on the problem, there are certain events after which the element is shown:

• Initially on page load
• When hovered
• The 3 second delay after hover exit

And certain events after which the element is hidden:

• 3 seconds after initial page load if it wasn't hovered again
• 3 seconds after hover exit

With this, we can define a few states and their related events (this will be the outline of our XState state machine!)

1. initial
   • on hover enter -> show
   • after 3s -> hide
2. show
   • on hover enter -> stay in show
   • on hover exit -> delay
3. delay
   • on hover enter -> show
   • after 3s -> hide
4. hide
   • on hover enter -> show

How will our machine look like?

import { setup } from "xstate";

const Tags = {
  SHOULD_SHOW: "machine.shouldShow",
} as const;

type Events =
  | {
      type: "HOVER_ENTER";
    }
  | {
      type: "HOVER_LEAVE";
    };

const hoverMachine = setup({
  actions: {},
  types: {
    events: {} as Events,
  },
}).createMachine({
  initial: "initial",
  states: {
    initial: {
      tags: [Tags.SHOULD_SHOW],
      on: {
        HOVER_LEAVE: {
          target: "delay",
        },
        HOVER_ENTER: {
          target: "show",
        },
      },
      after: {
        3000: "hide",
      },
    },
    show: {
      tags: [Tags.SHOULD_SHOW],
      on: {
        HOVER_LEAVE: {
          target: "delay",
        },
        HOVER_ENTER: {
          target: "show",
        },
      },
    },
    delay: {
      tags: [Tags.SHOULD_SHOW],
      after: {
        3000: {
          target: "hide",
        },
      },
      on: {
        HOVER_ENTER: {
          target: "show",
        },
      },
    },
    hide: {
      on: {
        HOVER_ENTER: {
          target: "show",
        },
      },
    },
  },
});

export { hoverMachine };

This is a simple state machine (which is very similar to our event based description that we made).

State descriptions

There's an initial state called initial (hah), which transitions to hide after 3 seconds in case there is no HOVER_ENTER/HOVER_LEAVE event.

If there is a HOVER_ENTER event, it transitions to show. From there it can go to delay after HOVER_LEAVE.

From delay, it can go to hide after 3 seconds, or back to show if there is a HOVER_ENTER event.

Finally from hide, it can go back to show if there is a HOVER_ENTER event.

You'll notice some of these states are tagged with Tags.SHOULD_SHOW. This marks those states as having a tag, which we use for the show state in our UI! Remember how we found out which states/events should show the element based on the problem? This tag helps us realise that.

The UI code (it's React sorry) 🙏

import { useActor } from "@xstate/react";
import { Tags, hoverMachine } from "./machine";

function App() {
  const [state, send] = useActor(hoverMachine);
  const shouldShow = state.hasTag(Tags.SHOULD_SHOW);
  return (
    <>
      <main
        className="..."
        onPointerEnter={() => {
          send({ type: "HOVER_ENTER" });
        }}
        onPointerLeave={() => {
          send({ type: "HOVER_LEAVE" });
        }}
      >
        <div className="...">
          <h1 className="...">
            Should show element: {shouldShow ? "yes" : "no"}
          </h1>
          <span>State machine state: {state.value}</span>
        </div>
      </main>
    </>
  );
}

The best part about state machines, you've avoided a lot of if-else soup. No need to wrestle with timers and their ids in UI. (No useEffect as well 👀)

You don't need to worry about your UI logic leaking into your business logic. You can completely decouple the two.

Sandbox

References:

• XState
• Core concepts

Feel free to contact me on Twitter for any questions or feedback, or if you find any mistakes in this. I'd love to hear from you!

Back to top